In 2011, while I was helping 3rd and 4th graders learn their multiplication facts by bouncing playground balls and stepping on polyspots, I observed that several students with ADHD and dyslexia had significant difficulty moving to and keeping a beat. In Play Math, we would bounce playground balls between partners on the downbeat with tempo, rhythm, and timing (TRT).
As we pushed the balls with two hands toward the ground on the beat, we would say our math facts. The observation that several students could not synchronize their verbalizations while bouncing the ball on a beat lead me to study the growing body of literature on beat perception, motor entrainment, and cognitive-physical activity. Current research suggests learning to move on a beat may influence the centers of the brain involved in academic learning and achievement. Yet, more research is underway. Here is what we know and what I wonder.
Children with developmental dyslexia have difficulty tapping to a beat.
Tapping in time to a metronome beat (hereafter beat synchronization) shows considerable variability in child populations, and individual differences in beat synchronization are reliably related to reading development. Children with developmental dyslexia show impairments in beat synchronization. These impairments may reflect deficiencies in auditory perception of the beat which in turn affect auditory-motor mapping, or may reflect an independent motor deficit. Colling LJ, Noble HL and Goswami U (2017) Neural Entrainment and Sensorimotor Synchronization to the Beat in Children with Developmental Dyslexia: An EEG Study. Front. Neurosci. 11:360. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2017.00360
Preschoolers who can entrain to an external beat have more faithful neural encoding of temporal modulations in speech and score higher on tests of early language skills. Beat synchronization abilities emerge at an early age, therefore, when children exhibit challenges matching their movements to a beat, the research may inform strategies for early detection of and intervention for language-based learning disabilities, Carr et al.2014.
The precision of beat synchronization is reduced in children with developmental dyslexia, Overy et al., 2003; Thomson and Goswami, 2008; Flaugnacco et al., 2014.
“For children with developmental dyslexia, it is unknown whether their impairments in beat synchronization arise from a primary sensory deficit in auditory rhythm perception which in turn affects the temporal precision of action, or whether beat synchronization is impaired via an independent deficit related to the developing motor system, or both,” Colling et al. 2017.
What we know…
- Beat perception, beat synchronization, motor timing and rhythm detection appear to be associated with regions of the brain often indicated in ADHD and developmental dyslexia,
- In neuroimaging studies, common subcortical and cortical brain areas activated in perceptual and motor timing tasks include the cerebellum (Jeuptner et al., 1997; Jeuptner and Weiller, 1998), basal ganglia (Harrington et al., 1998a; Schubotz et al., 2000; Rao et al., 2001; Ferrandez et al., 2003; Nenadic et al., 2003; Lewis et al., 2004; Grahn and Brett, 2007), supplementary motor area (Macar et al., 2002; Ferrandez et al., 2003; Coull, 2004; Macar et al., 2004; Grahn and Brett, 2007), premotor cortex (Schubotz et al., 2000; Schubotz and von Cramon, 2001), and prefrontal regions (Rubia et al., 1998; Lewis and Miall, 2002), Grahn & McAuley, 2009.
- Although beat perception develops spontaneously in humans , individuals vary widely in their ability to extract a beat from musical rhythm [45,46]. Some of this variability may result from musical training, which enhances beat perception abilities [23,36,47]. Bouwer et al., 2018.
- Beat perception and the ability to move to a beat are correlated with ADHD, Puyjarinet, 2017.
- Beat synchronization predicts neural speech encoding and reading readiness in preschoolers Carr et al. 2014.
- Subcortical structures including the basal ganglia and cerebellum are suggested to play a role in beat and rhythm perception Grahn & Brett, 2009; Grahn, 2009; Thaut et al. 2014; Tierney & Kraus, 2013.
- Beat and rhythm-based rehabilitation are reported in the treatment of Parkinson’s disease, Ashoori, 2015; Dalla Bella et al. 2017, with varying outcomes, more research is in progress. Musically cued gait-training is also an interesting line of inquiry.
4 Simple Coordinative Beat-Based Movements for Home and School
- Bounce a racquetball (they bounce well) first with your dominant hand then your non-dominant hand for 8 counts each with a consistent tempo. Pass the ball back to the other hand and begin again, do this for three sets. Then begin again starting with your non-dominant hand.
- Bounce a playground ball between two people. As you push the ball into a V between you, take turns spelling your entire name forward then backward, on the beat. Variation, use this activity to practice your spelling words or math facts, forward, then backward on the beat.
- March with big arm movements like a toy soldier to a metronome (they are free in the app store on your phone), accenting the downbeat for 32 beats at varying tempos, 85 BPM, 120 BPM, 160 BPM. Variations, march forward for 4 beats then backward for 4 beats; count as you march forward and backward 1,2,3,4; 1,2,3,4; instead of standing up tall, crouch down low and stomp out your patterns.
- Standing up, bounce your knees for 8 beats, then bounce 8 more, clapping every other beat, do three sets. Variation, try doing this on one foot for the first 8 bouncing beats, then both feet for the next bouncing and clapping beats.
Sincere gratitude to Alex Doman of Advanced Brain Technologies for introducing me to the auditory neuroscience research in 2014 and to Principal Diane Hale and Teacher, Bonnie Walker at Tarwater Elementary School for helping us improve our cognitive-motor activities for students. This year, Ashley Ezell, Sue Milano and the students at St. Francis Xavier helped us to improve our beat-based rhythmic classroom movement programs. Our lab schools make an enormous difference in the lives of students around the world, thank you!
Children with ADHD show deficits in many areas, including motor timing and beat perception.
A meta-analysis of timing functions in ADHD, including 11 fMRI studies of time discrimination, time estimation, motor timing and temporal discounting (temporal foresight), showed consistently reduced activation in 150 ADHD patients relative to 145 healthy controls in left IFC, left inferior parietal lobe and right lateral cerebellum (Hart et al., 2012), all key regions of timing functions (Wiener et al., 2010; see Figure 1E), Rubia 2018.
Children and adults with Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) fail in simple tasks like telling whether two sounds have different durations, or in reproducing single durations. The deficit is linked to poor reading, attention, and language skills. Research demonstrates that these timing distortions emerge also when tracking the beat of rhythmic sounds in perceptual and sensorimotor tasks. This contrasts with the common observation that durations are better perceived and produced when embedded in rhythmic stimuli. Children and adults with ADHD struggled when moving to the beat of rhythmic sounds, and when detecting deviations from the beat, Puyjarinet et al. 2017.
The Puyjarinet study found a deficit in generating an internal beat in ADHD while listening to rhythmic sounds, a function typically associated with the basal ganglia. Rhythm-based interventions aimed at reinstating or compensating this malfunctioning circuitry may be particularly valuable in ADHD, as already shown for other neurodevelopmental disorders, such as dyslexia and Specific Language Impairment.
Slater and Tate (2018), suggest that further investigation of the basis of rhythm and timing deficits could ultimately help to form a more integrated view of the etiologies of ADHD, bridging the gap between genetic factors (e.g., variation in dopaminergic signaling), neural dynamics and the development of cortical networks, and the behavioral control of cognition and movement. They highlighted that the same neural systems are strengthened in expert musicians, suggesting the potential for neuroplasticity to have remediating effects. This novel, interdisciplinary approach could inform therapeutic strategies, harnessing the rewarding properties of music to strengthen coordination within the brain.
What I wonder….
- What is the relationship between gross motor beat synchronization and learning in children?
- What is the relationship between coordinative bilateral upper and lower body beat synchronization and learning in children?
- How do coordinative beat-based movement activities stimulate the executive functions associated with learning in children?
- Might coordinative-rhythmic movement activities improve attention, memory, cognitive flexibility and response inhibition in children with learning challenges?
- When we improve beat competency in children with learning challenges (biologically based or due to low environmental brain stimulation), do their academic outcomes improve?
- What types of rhythms work best to improve executive functions in which types of children?
- If we provide high-quality music education beginning in preschool and extending through elementary school, will we see an improvement in math and reading scores for many children?
- If we add coordinative beat-based rhythmic motor activities in physical education, will we see an associated improvement in executive function skills in students?
Physically active classroom lessons improve academic achievement and time on task in many students, Szabo-Reed et al. 2019.
The Influence of Classroom Physical Activity Participation and Time on Task on Academic Achievement. A 3-year stratified RCT study conducted in 17 schools found that over the course of 2nd to 5th grade, two doses of 10 minutes of physically active academic lessons per day improved time on task, math and spelling scores but not reading scores. Read the entire study here.
Keeping the Beat: A Large Sample Study of Bouncing and Clapping to Music, Tranchant et al., 2016.
What makes a rhythm complex? The influence of musical training and accent type on beat perception, Bouwer et al., 2018.
Rhythm production at school entry as a predictor of poor reading and spelling at the end of first grade, Lundetrae & Thompson, 2018.
Does music training enhance literacy skills? A Meta-Analysis, Gordon et al., 2015.
Perspectives on the rhythm–grammar link and its implications for typical and atypical language development, Gordon et al., 2015.
Neural bases of individual differences in beat perception, Grahn & McAuley, 2009.
The Evolution of Rhythm Cognition: Timing in Music and Speech, Ravignani et al., 2017.
A longitudinal study on gross motor development in children with learning disorders, Westendorp et al., 2014.